MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS


COA Case Number: 267191
SCt Case Number: 135028
HATTIE MOORE V SECURA INS
1  MOORE HATTIE
  Oral Argument: Y  Timely: Y
PL-AE RET
(47546) BADE PETER M
140 E 2ND STREET
SUITE 215
FLINT  MI 48502
810-244-5862
2  MOORE JAMES
PL-AE SAM
 

3  SECURA INS
  Oral Argument: Y  Timely: Y
DF-AT RET
(61978) CAVANAGH MEGAN K
1000 WOODBRIDGE STREET
DETROIT  MI 48207-3192
313-446-1530

Status: Case Concluded; File Archived    SCT Status: CLOSE
Remarks: Related: 265535-F

12/13/20051Claim of Appeal - Civil
Proof Of Service Date: 12/13/2005
Check #: 69027 Fee: $375.00
Receipt#: 2671911
Jurisdictional Checklist: Y  Register of Actions: Y
Attorney:61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
11/22/20052Order Appealed From
From: GENESEE COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT
Case Number: 01-071881-NF
Trial Court Judge: 11303 BROWN THOMAS LEO
Nature of Case:
     Attorney Fees & Costs
11/22/20055Order Appealed From
From: GENESEE COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT
Case Number: 02-073203-NF
Trial Court Judge: 11303 BROWN THOMAS LEO
Nature of Case:
     Attorney Fees & Costs
12/13/20056Other
Date: 12/13/2005
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
Attorney: 61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
Comments: statement that transcript has been ordered
12/13/20057Transcript Requested by Atty or Party
Date: 9/27/2005 Timely: Y
Reporter: 6913 - ROBINSON SHELIE M
Filed By Attorney: 61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
Hearings:
     9/15/2004
     6/7/2005
     6/8/2005
     6/9/2005
     6/10/2005
     8/22/2005
     9/7/2005
12/13/20058Transcript Ordered by Trial Court
Date: 11/29/2005 Timely: Y
Reporter: 6913 - ROBINSON SHELIE M
Filed By Attorney: 61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
Hearings:
     11/22/2005
12/29/20059Transcript Overdue - Notice to Reporter
Mail Date: 12/29/2005
Reporter: 6913 - ROBINSON SHELIE M
Comments: Transcripts in Event 7 are overdue from Ct Rptr Robinson.
01/12/200610Invol Dismissal Warning - No Transcript
Attorney: 61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
Due Date: 2/2/2006
Comments: Trs in Event 7 are overdue from Ct Rptr Robinson. Se also Event 9.
01/12/200611Docketing Statement MCR 7.204H
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
Proof Of Service Date: 1/10/2006
Filed By Attorney: 61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
01/17/200612Notice of Filing Transcript
Date: 1/10/2006 Timely: Y
Reporter: 6913 - ROBINSON SHELIE M
Hearings:
     9/15/2004
     6/7/2005
     6/8/2005
     6/9/2005
     6/10/2005
     8/22/2005
     9/7/2005
     11/22/2005
01/30/200613Order: Settlement Conference - Scheduled
Panel: PMD
Comments: briefing not stayed
02/06/200614Appearance - Appellee
Date: 2/1/2006
For Party: 1 MOORE HATTIE PL-AE
Attorney: 47546 - BADE PETER M
02/27/200615Stips: Extend Time - AT Brief
Extend Until: 4/4/2006
Filed By Attorney: 61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
04/04/200616Motion: Extend Time - Appellant
Proof Of Service Date: 4/4/2006
Check No.: 75320 Fee: $100.00 Receipt #: 2671912
Filed By Attorney: 61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
Requested Extension: 5/2/2006
Answer Due: 4/11/2006
04/11/200617Submitted On Administrative Motion Docket
Event: 16 Extend Time - Appellant
District: T
04/12/200618Order: Extend Time - Appellant Brief - Grant
Click here to view document in PDF format.
Event: 16 Extend Time - Appellant
Panel: PMD
Attorney: 61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
Extension Date: 5/2/2006
05/02/200619Brief: Appellant
Proof Of Service Date: 5/2/2006
Oral Argument Requested: Y  Timely Filed: Y  
Filed By Attorney: 61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
Comments: timely by order-see event 18
05/08/200620Other
Date: 5/4/2006
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
Attorney: 61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
Comments: missing pages to exhibit D of appellant's brief-omitted in error
05/09/200621Defective Filing Letter
Event: 20
     PROOF OF SERVICE - Cured
05/11/200622Defect Cured
Event: 20
P/S Date: 5/4/2006
     PROOF OF SERVICE - Cured
06/06/200623Brief: Appellee
Proof Of Service Date: 6/6/2006
Oral Argument Requested: Y  Timely Filed: Y  
Filed By Attorney: 47546 - BADE PETER M
For Party: 1 MOORE HATTIE PL-AE
06/07/200624Defective Filing Letter
Event: 23
     Proof of Service - Cured
06/09/200625Defect Cured
Event: 23
P/S Date: 6/6/2006
     Proof of Service - Cured
06/14/200626Order: Settlement Conference - Concluded
Click here to view document in PDF format.
Panel: PMD
Comments: time expired; restore to regular docket
06/14/200627Noticed
Record: REQST Mail Date: 6/15/2006
06/28/200628Record Filed
Comments: BXS(2):BX(1):LCF(TRS INCL);8 TRS(brn fldr:5 trs);4 DEPS;BRN FLDR(MISC PLDGS);(#02-073203-NF).......
06/28/200629Record Filed
Comments: CONT..BX(2):3 LCF;BR FLDR(4 TRS);(#01-071881-NF)-GENESEE CO.
07/11/200631Motion: Extend Time - Reply Brief
Proof Of Service Date: 7/11/2006
Check No.: 80301 Fee: $100.00 Receipt #: 2671913
Filed By Attorney: 37942 - SAYLOR DANIEL S
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
Requested Extension: 7/11/2006
Answer Due: 7/18/2006
Comments: reply brief filed with motion
07/11/200634Brief: Reply
Proof Of Service Date: 7/11/2006
Oral Argument Requested:   Timely Filed: Y  
Filed By Attorney: 37942 - SAYLOR DANIEL S
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
Comments: timely by order-see event 33
07/18/200632Submitted On Administrative Motion Docket
Event: 31 Extend Time - Reply Brief
District: T
07/20/200633Order: Extend Time - Reply Brief - Grant
Click here to view document in PDF format.
Event: 31 Extend Time - Reply Brief
Panel: PMD
Attorney: 37942 - SAYLOR DANIEL S
Extension Date: 7/11/2006
Comments: reply brief that was received on 7/11/06 is accepted for filing
04/05/200739Submitted on Case Call
District: D Item #: 20
Panel: KTW,DHS,ATD
04/27/200752Brief: Supplemental Auth`y
Proof Of Service Date: 4/26/2007
Oral Argument Requested:   Timely Filed:  
Filed By Attorney: 47546 - BADE PETER M
For Party: 1 MOORE HATTIE PL-AE
04/27/200753Proof of Service - Generic
Date: 4/27/2007
For Party: 1 MOORE HATTIE PL-AE
Attorney: 47546 - BADE PETER M
Comments: amended proof of service of supp authority to indicate correct doc served
04/30/200754Brief: Supplemental Auth`y
Proof Of Service Date: 4/30/2007
Oral Argument Requested:   Timely Filed:  
Filed By Attorney: 61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
07/03/200759Opinion - Authored - Published
Click here to view document in PDF format.
Pages: 5  
Panel: KTW,DHS,ATD  Author: ATD
Result: L/Ct Judgment/Order Affirmed
07/03/200760Opinion - Dissenting
Click here to view document in PDF format.
Pages: 6  
Author: KTW
07/24/200761Motion: Reconsideration of Opinion
Proof Of Service Date: 7/24/2007
Check No.: 299758 Fee: $100.00 Receipt #: 2671914
Filed By Attorney: 61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
Answer Due: 8/7/2007
08/06/200763Answer - Reconsideration
Proof Of Service Date: 8/3/2007
Event No: 61 Reconsideration of Opinion
For Party: 1 MOORE HATTIE PL-AE
Filed By Attorney: 47546 - BADE PETER M
08/07/200762Submitted On Reconsideration Docket
Event: 61 Reconsideration of Opinion
District: C Item #: 1
08/30/200764Order: Reconsideration - Deny - Appeal Remains Closed
Click here to view document in PDF format.
Event: 61 Reconsideration of Opinion
Panel: KTW,DHS,ATD
Comments: KT Wilder would grant reconsideration
10/11/200765SCt: Application for Leave to SCt
Supreme Court No. 135028
Notice Date: 11/6/2007
Fee: Invoiced   Check No.:39933
For Party: 3
Attorney: 61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
10/16/200766Supreme Court - File & Record Sent To
File Location: Z
Comments: sc#135028 2-box case**4 lcf(trs incl);17 tr;4 dep;folder(misc)
10/17/200767SCt: COA and TCt Received
17 tr; 4 dep;4 files
11/06/200768SCt: Brief in Opposition to SCt Application
Filing Date: 11/6/2007
For Party: 1 MOORE HATTIE PL-AE
Filed By Attorney:47546 - BADE PETER M
Comments: by PLAE
01/15/200869Michigan Appeals Reports Publication
276 Mich App 195
01/30/200870SCt Order: Hold in Abeyance
Click here to view document in PDF format.
02/01/200871SCt: Miscellaneous Filing
Filing Date: 2/1/2008
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
Filed By Attorney:61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
Comments: DFAT's supplement in support of APPL
07/08/200872SCt: Miscellaneous Filing
Filing Date: 7/8/2008
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
Filed By Attorney:61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
Comments: DFAT's second supplement in support of APPL
07/25/200873SCt Order: Misc Order - See Notes
Click here to view document in PDF format.
09/04/200874SCt: Miscellaneous Filing
Filing Date: 9/4/2008
For Party: 1 MOORE HATTIE PL-AE
Filed By Attorney:47546 - BADE PETER M
Comments: PLAE's supplement as per order
09/05/200875SCt: Miscellaneous Filing
Filing Date: 9/5/2008
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
Filed By Attorney:61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
Comments: DFAT's supplement as per order
10/02/200876SCt: Oral Arguments Held
Filing Date: 10/2/2008
Filed By Attorney:61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
OA: Y  
Comments: Orally argued on Appl for Lv to Appeal as provided in MCR 7.302(G)(1)
12/30/200877SCt Opinion on Application - Reverse CoA
Click here to view document in PDF format.
01/20/200978SCt Motion: Rehearing
Notice Date: 01/20/2009
Check No.: 34476
Party: 1
Filed By Attorney: 47546 - BADE PETER M
Comments:  Rehearing #555
01/22/200981Bill of Costs Filed
Date: 1/22/2009
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
Attorney: 61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
01/23/200979SCt: Miscellaneous Filing
Filing Date: 1/23/2009
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
Filed By Attorney:61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
Comments: Df-At bill of costs
01/30/200980SCt: Answer to Pleading at SCt
Filing Date: 1/30/2009
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
Filed By Attorney:61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
Comments: answer to motion for rehearing
01/30/200982Objection to Bill of Costs
Date: 1/28/2009
For Party: 1 MOORE HATTIE PL-AE
Attorney: 47546 - BADE PETER M
04/03/200983SCt Order: Deny Rehearing
Click here to view document in PDF format.
04/08/200984SCt Order: Misc Order - See Notes
04/17/200985Costs Taxed Per MCR 7.219
Fee: $4,429.50
For Party: 3 SECURA INS DF-AT
Attorney: 61978 - CAVANAGH MEGAN K
12/02/200986SCt Order: Misc Order - See Notes
12/11/200987Supreme Court - File Ret`d By - Close Out
File Location: F

Case Listing Complete