MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS
ISSUES PENDING BEFORE THE SUPREME COURT


APPEAL AND ERROR
   Error - Harmless
 
In re Hansen 285 Mich App 158 (2009),   OWENS, Servitto, Gleicher
 
 
   Presentation - Statement of Questions - Failure
 
In re Hansen 285 Mich App 158 (2009),   OWENS, Servitto, Gleicher
 
 
   Preservation - Failure - Consideration - Question of Law
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Preservation - Failure - Dismissal - Suppression of Evidence
 
People v Richmond (#277012, rel'd 4/22/08),   Kelly, Owens, Schuette (PC)
 
 
   Preservation - Failure - Forfeiture
 
People v Redd (#283934, rel'd 12/4/08),   Meter, Talbot, Murray (PC)
 
 
   Preservation - Failure - Forfeiture/Waiver
 
People v Redd (#283934, rel'd 12/4/08),   Meter, Talbot, Murray (PC)
 
 
   Preservation - Failure - Not Raised
 
In re Hansen 285 Mich App 158 (2009),   OWENS, Servitto, Gleicher
 
 
   Preservation - Failure - Not Raised - Reconsideration - Effect
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Preservation - Failure - Review - Standard
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Preservation - Failure - Waiver - Acquiescence at Trial
 
People v Redd (#283934, rel'd 12/4/08),   Meter, Talbot, Murray (PC)
 
 
   Preservation - Failure - Waiver - Effect
 
People v Redd (#283934, rel'd 12/4/08),   Meter, Talbot, Murray (PC)
 
 
   Review - Harmless Error
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Review - Standard - Abuse of Discretion - Standard
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Review - Standard - Constitutional Error - Preservation - Failure
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Review - Standard - Harmless Error - Criminal Conviction - Nonconstitutional Error - Preserved
 
People v Mardlin (#279699, rel'd 5/5/09),   Zahra, O'Connell, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Review - Standard - Question of Law
 
Tkachik v Mandeville 282 Mich App 364; 764 NW2d 318 (2009),   Murphy, KF KELLY, Donofrio
 
 
   Review - Standard - Question of Law - Doctrine - Applicability
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   Stare Decisis
 
O'Neal v St John Hospital & Medical Center (#277317, rel'd 11/4/08),   Wilder, Jansen, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Stare Decisis - Court of Appeals - Opinions - Precedential Effect - Before November 1, 1990
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Stare Decisis - Court of Appeals - Opinions - Unpublished - Precedential Effect
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Stare Decisis - Federal Decision
 
Holman v Rasak 281 Mich App 507; 761 NW2d 391 (2008),   Jansen, O'Connell, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Stare Decisis - Supreme Court
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 

CIVIL PROCEDURE
   Claims - Nature - Determination
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   Costs - Award - Review - Standard
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Costs - Expert Witness Fees - Review - Standard
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Costs - Prevailing Party
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Costs - Prevailing Party - Exception - Public Question - Zoning - Validity
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Costs - Prevailing Party - Exception - Public Question - Zoning - Validity
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Costs - Prevailing Party - Expert Witness Fees
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Discovery - Admissions - Denial - Reasonable Ground
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Discovery - Admissions - Purpose
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Discovery - Admissions - Sanctions - Review - Standard
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Discovery - Admissions - Sanctions - Standard
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Discovery - Privilege - Physician/Patient - Ex Parte Interview - Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act
 
Holman v Rasak 281 Mich App 507; 761 NW2d 391 (2008),   Jansen, O'Connell, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Discovery - Review - Standard
 
Holman v Rasak 281 Mich App 507; 761 NW2d 391 (2008),   Jansen, O'Connell, Owens (PC)
 
 

CIVIL RIGHTS
   Elliott-Larsen Civil Rights Act - Claim - Vanue - Violation/Injury
 
Brightwell v Fifth Third Bank of Michigan (#280820, rel'd 4/9/09),   Talbot, Bandstra, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Religious Land Use Act - Burden on Religion - Zoning - Variance - Denial
 
Shepherd Montessori Center Milan v Ann Arbor Township (On Remand) 280 Mich App 449; 761 NW2d 230 (2008),   SAAD, Hoekstra, Smolenski
 
 
   Section 1983 Action - Attorney Fees - Prevailing Party - Necessity
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Section 1983 Action - Attorney Fees - Purpose
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 

COMMERCIAL LAW
   UCC - Applicability - Recreational Vehicles - Purchase Contract
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   UCC - Common Law - Effect
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   UCC - Revocation of Acceptance - Effect - Alternative Remedies
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   UCC - Revocation of Acceptance - Privity - Necessity
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   Warranty - Breach - Remedy - Rescission/Revocation of Acceptance
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   Warranty - Implied - Breach - Rescission - Manufacturer/Consumer
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   Warranty - Magnuson-Moss Act - Construction - Federal Courts - Effect
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   Warranty - Magnuson-Moss Act - Implied Warranty - State Law
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   Warranty - Magnuson-Moss Act - Supplier - Definition
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   Warranty - Magnuson-Moss Act - Violation - Remedy
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   Warranty - Third Party Beneficiary - Effect
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW
   Equal Protection - Review - Standard
 
Shepherd Montessori Center Milan v Ann Arbor Township (On Remand) 280 Mich App 449; 761 NW2d 230 (2008),   SAAD, Hoekstra, Smolenski
 
 
   Headlee Amendment - Enforcement - Costs - Attorney Fees - Prevailing Party - Partial - Effect
 
Adair v State (On Second Remand) 279 Mich App 507 (2008),   Saad, TALBOT, Fort Hood
 
 
   Headlee Amendment - State Funding - Required Services - Increase - Costs
 
Adair v State (On Second Remand) 279 Mich App 507 (2008),   Saad, TALBOT, Fort Hood
 
 
   Impairment of Contract - Test
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Review - Standard
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 

CONSUMER LAW
   Damages - Economic Loss
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   Lemon Law - Applicability - Motor Homes
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   Lemon Law - Applicability - Recreational Vehicles
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 

CONTRACTS
   Damages - Economic Loss - Applicability
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   Rescission - Privity - Necessity
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 

COUNSEL
   Effective Assistance - Futile Objection
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Effective Assistance - Presumption - Burden of Proof
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Effective Assistance - Presumption - Burden of Proof
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Effective Assistance - Review - Record
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Effective Assistance - Standard
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Effective Assistance - Standard
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Effective Assistance - Trial Strategy - Objection - Failure - Closing Argument
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 

CRIMES
   Agricultural Commodities Marketing Act - Assessments - Payment - Failure
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Child Sexual Abuse - Abusive Material - Definition
 
People v Flick (#277925, rel'd 12/23/08),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Child Sexual Abuse - Abusive Material - Possession
 
People v Flick (#277925, rel'd 12/23/08),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Child Sexual Abuse - Abusive Material - Possession - Computer
 
People v Flick (#277925, rel'd 12/23/08),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Child Sexual Abuse - Abusive Material - Possession - Computer - Internet Viewing
 
People v Flick (#277925, rel'd 12/23/08),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Child Sexual Abuse - Abusive Material - Possession - Knowing - Computer - Temporary Internet Files
 
People v Flick (#277925, rel'd 12/23/08),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Child Sexual Abuse - Abusive Material - Possession/Production
 
People v Hill (#281055, rel'd 2/19/09),   Sawyer, Servitto, MJ Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Child Sexual Abuse - Abusive Material - Production - Computer - Copy - Compact Disk
 
People v Hill (#281055, rel'd 2/19/09),   Sawyer, Servitto, MJ Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Child Sexual Abuse - Abusive Material - Production - Coputer - Download
 
People v Hill (#281055, rel'd 2/19/09),   Sawyer, Servitto, MJ Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Drunk Driving - OWI - Controlled Substance - Schedule 1 - Causation - Proximate - Necessity
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Drunk Driving - OWI - Controlled Substance - Schedule 1 - Constitutionality - Due Process
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Drunk Driving - OWI Causing Death - Elements - Causation - Determination
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Drunk Driving - OWI Causing Death - Elements - Causation - Proximate Cause - Necessity
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Drunk Driving - OWI Causing Death - Elements - Causation - Superseding Cause
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Elements - Causation - Proximate - Superseding Cause - Definition
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Elements - Causation - Proximate - Superseding Cause - Victim - Gross Negligence
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   False Pretenses - Elements
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   False Pretenses - Elements - Intent to Pass Title
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   False Pretenses - Obtaining Property
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Felon in Possession of Firearm
 
People v Dupree 284 Mich App 89 (2009),   Murray (dissenting), Gleicher (concurring), MJ KELLY
 
 
   Felon in Possession of Firearm - Purpose
 
People v Dupree 284 Mich App 89 (2009),   Murray (dissenting), Gleicher (concurring), MJ KELLY
 
 
   Home Invasion - First Degree
 
People v Wilder (#278737, rel'd 10/21/08),   Meter (concurring), Talbot, Murray (PC)
 
 
   Home Invasion - Third Degree
 
People v Wilder (#278737, rel'd 10/21/08),   Meter (concurring), Talbot, Murray (PC)
 
 
   Solicitation to Commit Murder - Elements
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Witness Intimidation
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Witness Intimidation - Threat - Definition
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 

CRIMINAL DEFENSES
   Affirmative Defenses - Definition
 
People v Dupree 284 Mich App 89 (2009),   Murray (dissenting), Gleicher (concurring), MJ KELLY
 
 
   Duress - Applicability - Felon in Possession of Firearm
 
People v Dupree 284 Mich App 89 (2009),   Murray (dissenting), Gleicher (concurring), MJ KELLY
 
 
   Duress - Burden of Proof
 
People v Dupree 284 Mich App 89 (2009),   Murray (dissenting), Gleicher (concurring), MJ KELLY
 
 
   Duress - Elements
 
People v Dupree 284 Mich App 89 (2009),   Murray (dissenting), Gleicher (concurring), MJ KELLY
 
 
   Necessity - Applicability - Felon in Possession of Firearm
 
People v Dupree 284 Mich App 89 (2009),   Murray (dissenting), Gleicher (concurring), MJ KELLY
 
 
   Necessity - Burden of Proof
 
People v Dupree 284 Mich App 89 (2009),   Murray (dissenting), Gleicher (concurring), MJ KELLY
 
 
   Self-Defense - Applicability - Felon in Possession of Firearm
 
People v Dupree 284 Mich App 89 (2009),   Murray (dissenting), Gleicher (concurring), MJ KELLY
 
 
   Self-Defense - Burden of Proof
 
People v Dupree 284 Mich App 89 (2009),   Murray (dissenting), Gleicher (concurring), MJ KELLY
 
 
   Self-Defense - Standard
 
People v Dupree 284 Mich App 89 (2009),   Murray (dissenting), Gleicher (concurring), MJ KELLY
 
 

DAMAGES
   Economic Loss - Applicability - Warranty
 
Davis v Forest River, Inc 278 Mich App 76; 748 NW2d 887 (2008),   Owens, Bandstra (dissenting), DAVIS
 
 
   Interest - Contractual/Statutory - Constitutionality - Impairment of Contract
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Interest - Court of Claims - Constitutionality - Impairment of Contract
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Interest - Postjudgment - Court of Claims
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Interest - Prejudgment - Court of Claims - Applicability - Constitutional Tort
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 

DECLARATORY JUDGMENT
   Administrative Agency - Declaratory Ruling - Necessity
 
Insurance Institute of Michigan v Commissioner of the Office of Financial and Insurance Services 280 Mich App 333; 761 NW2d 184 (2008),   WHITE, Zahra (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Kelly (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 

DOMESTIC RELATIONS
   Child Custody - Best Interest of Child - Factors
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Best Interest of Child - Factors - Preference of Child - Reasonableness
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Best Interest of Child - Factors - Weight
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Best Interest of Child - Review - Error - Remand - Necessity
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Child Custody Act - Purpose
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Custodial Environment - Change - Change of Domicile/School
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Custodial Environment - Custody Order - Effect
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Custodial Environment - Multiple Homes
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Custodial Environment - Standard
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Joint - Important Decisions - Educational Issues
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Joint - Important Decisions - Shared Decisionmaking
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Joint - Lack of Cooperation - Effect
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Joint - Lack of Cooperation - Effect - Best Interest of Child - Burden of Proof
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Joint - Lack of Cooperation - Effect - Best Interest of Child - Determination
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Modification - Burden of Proof
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Modification - Change in Residence - Less Than 100 Miles - Consent - Necessity
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Modification - Custodial Environment - Both Parents - Burden of Proof
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Modification - Grounds - Necessity
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Child Custody - Review - Standard
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Divorce - Jurisdiction - Death of Party
 
Tkachik v Mandeville 282 Mich App 364; 764 NW2d 318 (2009),   Murphy, KF KELLY, Donofrio
 
 
   Parents - Waiver - Child's Claims - Before Injury - Validity
 
Woodman v Kera, LLC 280 Mich App 125 (2008),   TALBOT, Bandstra (concurring), Schuette (concurring)
 
 
   Parents - Waiver - Child's Claims - Power - Construction - Strict
 
Woodman v Kera, LLC 280 Mich App 125 (2008),   TALBOT, Bandstra (concurring), Schuette (concurring)
 
 
   Parents - Waiver - Child's Claims - Validity
 
Woodman v Kera, LLC 280 Mich App 125 (2008),   TALBOT, Bandstra (concurring), Schuette (concurring)
 
 

DUE PROCESS
   Notice - Property Owner - Address - Deed
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Notice - Property Owner - Reasonableness - Standard
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Review - Standard
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Review - Standard
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 

EQUITY
   Contribution
 
Tkachik v Mandeville 282 Mich App 364; 764 NW2d 318 (2009),   Murphy, KF KELLY, Donofrio
 
 
   Injunction - Review - Standard
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Review - Standard
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Unjust Enrichment - Definition
 
Tkachik v Mandeville 282 Mich App 364; 764 NW2d 318 (2009),   Murphy, KF KELLY, Donofrio
 
 

EVIDENCE
   Admissibility - Error - Harmless - Standard
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Admissibility - Prejudice - Test
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Admissibility - Prejudice/Relevancy - Determination
 
People v Mardlin (#279699, rel'd 5/5/09),   Zahra, O'Connell, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Admissibility - Relevancy - Burden of Proof
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Admissibility - Relevancy - Doctrine of Chances
 
People v Mardlin (#279699, rel'd 5/5/09),   Zahra, O'Connell, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Admissibility - Relevancy - Standard
 
People v Mardlin (#279699, rel'd 5/5/09),   Zahra, O'Connell, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Admissibility - Relevancy - Standard
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Admissibility - Review - Standard
 
People v Mardlin (#279699, rel'd 5/5/09),   Zahra, O'Connell, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Admissibility - Review - Standard
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Admissibility - Review - Standard
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Admissibility - Review - Standard
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Admissibility - Review - Standard - Harmless Error
 
People v Gursky (#274949, rel'd 7/17/08),   Fitzgerald, Talbot, Donofrio (PC)
 
 
   Bad Acts - Admissibility
 
People v Mardlin (#279699, rel'd 5/5/09),   Zahra, O'Connell, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Bad Acts - Admissibility - Identity - Standard
 
People v Mardlin (#279699, rel'd 5/5/09),   Zahra, O'Connell, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Bad Acts - Admissibility - Motive
 
People v Mardlin (#279699, rel'd 5/5/09),   Zahra, O'Connell, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Bad Acts - Admissibility - Purpose - Noncharacter
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Bad Acts - Admissibility - Relevance
 
People v Mardlin (#279699, rel'd 5/5/09),   Zahra, O'Connell, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Bad Acts - Admissibility - Relevance - Burden of Proof
 
People v Mardlin (#279699, rel'd 5/5/09),   Zahra, O'Connell, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Bad Acts - Admissibility - Standard
 
People v Mardlin (#279699, rel'd 5/5/09),   Zahra, O'Connell, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Burden of Proof - Allocation - Review - Standard
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Burden of Proof - Standard - Review - Standard
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Hearsay - Exception - Tender Years - CSC - Standard - Spontaneity
 
People v Gursky (#274949, rel'd 7/17/08),   Fitzgerald, Talbot, Donofrio (PC)
 
 
   Privilege - Physician/Patient - Waiver - Lawsuit - Abrogation - Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act
 
Holman v Rasak 281 Mich App 507; 761 NW2d 391 (2008),   Jansen, O'Connell, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Silence - Adoptive Statement - Statement - Definition
 
People v Redd (#283934, rel'd 12/4/08),   Meter, Talbot, Murray (PC)
 
 
   Sufficiency - Criminal - Standard
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 

GOVERNMENT
   Register of Deeds - Duty/Power - Records - Name Index
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 

INSTRUCTIONS - CRIMINAL
   Elements - Necessity
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Lesser Included Offense - Cognate - Standard
 
People v Wilder (#278737, rel'd 10/21/08),   Meter (concurring), Talbot, Murray (PC)
 
 
   Lesser Included Offense - Home Invasion - First/Third Degree
 
People v Wilder (#278737, rel'd 10/21/08),   Meter (concurring), Talbot, Murray (PC)
 
 
   Lesser Included Offense - Necessarily Included - Standard
 
People v Wilder (#278737, rel'd 10/21/08),   Meter (concurring), Talbot, Murray (PC)
 
 
   Review - Standard
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Review - Standard
 
People v Dupree 284 Mich App 89 (2009),   Murray (dissenting), Gleicher (concurring), MJ KELLY
 
 
   Review - Standard - No Objection
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Review - Waiver - Satisfaction Expressed
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Review - Waiver - Satisfaction Expressed
 
People v Redd (#283934, rel'd 12/4/08),   Meter, Talbot, Murray (PC)
 
 

INSURANCE
   Health - Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act - Patient Information - Confidentiality
 
Holman v Rasak 281 Mich App 507; 761 NW2d 391 (2008),   Jansen, O'Connell, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Health - Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act - Protected Health Information - Applicability - Oral/Written
 
Holman v Rasak 281 Mich App 507; 761 NW2d 391 (2008),   Jansen, O'Connell, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Health - Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act - Protected Health Information - Disclosure - Judicial Proceedings - Qualified Protective Order - Definition
 
Holman v Rasak 281 Mich App 507; 761 NW2d 391 (2008),   Jansen, O'Connell, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Health - Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act - Protected Health Information - Disclosure - Judicial Proceedings - Qualified Protective Order - Ex Parte Interview
 
Holman v Rasak 281 Mich App 507; 761 NW2d 391 (2008),   Jansen, O'Connell, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Health - Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act - Protected Health Information - Disclosure - Judicial Proceedings - Standard
 
Holman v Rasak 281 Mich App 507; 761 NW2d 391 (2008),   Jansen, O'Connell, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Health - Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act - Protected Health Information - Disclosure - Limitations
 
Holman v Rasak 281 Mich App 507; 761 NW2d 391 (2008),   Jansen, O'Connell, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Insurance Commissioner - Rules - Review - Insurance Code - Necessity
 
Insurance Institute of Michigan v Commissioner of the Office of Financial and Insurance Services 280 Mich App 333; 761 NW2d 184 (2008),   WHITE, Zahra (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Kelly (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Insurance Commissioner - Rules - Review - Record
 
Insurance Institute of Michigan v Commissioner of the Office of Financial and Insurance Services 280 Mich App 333; 761 NW2d 184 (2008),   WHITE, Zahra (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Kelly (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Premium - Calculation - Credit Scores - Prohibition - Constitutionality - Due Process
 
Insurance Institute of Michigan v Commissioner of the Office of Financial and Insurance Services 280 Mich App 333; 761 NW2d 184 (2008),   WHITE, Zahra (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Kelly (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Premium - Calculation - Credit Scores - Prohibition - Validity
 
Insurance Institute of Michigan v Commissioner of the Office of Financial and Insurance Services 280 Mich App 333; 761 NW2d 184 (2008),   WHITE, Zahra (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Kelly (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 

INSURANCE - AUTOMOBILE
   Benefits - Payment - Failure - Reasonableness - Review - Standard
 
Hoover v Michigan Mutual Insurance Co 281 Mich App 617 (2008),   Schuette (concurring in part; dissenting in part), MURPHY, Fitzgerald
 
 
   Benefits - Personal Protection - Allowable Expenses - Housing
 
Hoover v Michigan Mutual Insurance Co 281 Mich App 617 (2008),   Schuette (concurring in part; dissenting in part), MURPHY, Fitzgerald
 
 
   Benefits - Personal Protection - Allowable Expenses - Requirements - Causation
 
Hoover v Michigan Mutual Insurance Co 281 Mich App 617 (2008),   Schuette (concurring in part; dissenting in part), MURPHY, Fitzgerald
 
 
   Benefits - Personal Protection - Allowable Expenses - Review - Standard
 
Hoover v Michigan Mutual Insurance Co 281 Mich App 617 (2008),   Schuette (concurring in part; dissenting in part), MURPHY, Fitzgerald
 
 
   Limitations Period - Personal Protection Benefits - One Year Back - Applicability - State
 
University of Michigan Regents v Titan Insurance Co (#276710, rel'd 6/5/08)   Davis, Murray, Beckering (PC)
 
 
   Tort Liability - Serious Impairment - Standard
 
McCormick v Carrier (#275888, rel'd 3/25/08),   Whitbeck, Jansen, Davis (PC)
 
 

JUDICIARY
   Findings of Fact - Review - Standard
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Findings of Fact - Review - Standard
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Findings of Fact/Law - Review - Standard
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 

JURISDICTION AND VENUE
   Venue - Change - Burden of Proof
 
Brightwell v Fifth Third Bank of Michigan (#280820, rel'd 4/9/09),   Talbot, Bandstra, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Venue - Change - Necessity
 
Brightwell v Fifth Third Bank of Michigan (#280820, rel'd 4/9/09),   Talbot, Bandstra, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Venue - Change - Review - Standard
 
Brightwell v Fifth Third Bank of Michigan (#280820, rel'd 4/9/09),   Talbot, Bandstra, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Venue - Civil Rights
 
Brightwell v Fifth Third Bank of Michigan (#280820, rel'd 4/9/09),   Talbot, Bandstra, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Venue - Civil Rights - Test - Corporate Decision
 
Brightwell v Fifth Third Bank of Michigan (#280820, rel'd 4/9/09),   Talbot, Bandstra, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Venue - Criminal - Burden of Proof
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Venue - Criminal - Locus of Crime - Necessity - Due Process
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Venue - Criminal - Multiple Acts - Act/Effect
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Venue - Criminal - Obstruction of Justice - Witness Intimidation - Affected Proceeding
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Venue - Criminal - Review - Standard
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Venue - Criminal - Solicitation to Murder - Witness - Affected Proceeding
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Venue - Review - Preservation - Necessity
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 

JURY
   Challenge - Peremptory - Discrimination - Prohibition
 
Pellegrino v Ampco Systems Parking (#274743, rel'd 5/27/08),   O'Connell (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Borrello, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Challenge - Peremptory - Racial Discrimination - Racial Balance
 
Pellegrino v Ampco Systems Parking (#274743, rel'd 5/27/08),   O'Connell (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Borrello, Gleicher (PC)
 
 

JUVENILE LAW
   Parental Rights - Termination - Best Interest of Child - Determination - Amendment - Applicability
 
In re Hansen 285 Mich App 158 (2009),   OWENS, Servitto, Gleicher
 
 
   Parental Rights - Termination - Best Interest of Child - Findings of Fact - Necessity
 
In re Hansen 285 Mich App 158 (2009),   OWENS, Servitto, Gleicher
 
 
   Parental Rights - Termination - Continuing Conditions - Imprisonment
 
In re Hansen 285 Mich App 158 (2009),   OWENS, Servitto, Gleicher
 
 
   Parental Rights - Termination - Grounds - Necessity
 
In re Hansen 285 Mich App 158 (2009),   OWENS, Servitto, Gleicher
 
 
   Parental Rights - Termination - Imprisonment
 
In re Hansen 285 Mich App 158 (2009),   OWENS, Servitto, Gleicher
 
 
   Parental Rights - Termination - Proper Care and Custody - Placement with Relative
 
In re Hansen 285 Mich App 158 (2009),   OWENS, Servitto, Gleicher
 
 
   Parental Rights - Termination - Review - Standard
 
In re Hansen 285 Mich App 158 (2009),   OWENS, Servitto, Gleicher
 
 

MALPRACTICE
   Medical - Causation - Proximate Cause - Burden of Proof
 
O'Neal v St John Hospital & Medical Center (#277317, rel'd 11/4/08),   Wilder, Jansen, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Medical - Causation - Proximate Cause - Evidence - Sufficiency - Summary Disposition
 
O'Neal v St John Hospital & Medical Center (#277317, rel'd 11/4/08),   Wilder, Jansen, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Medical - Elements
 
O'Neal v St John Hospital & Medical Center (#277317, rel'd 11/4/08),   Wilder, Jansen, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Medical - Lost Opportunity to Avoid Harm
 
O'Neal v St John Hospital & Medical Center (#277317, rel'd 11/4/08),   Wilder, Jansen, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Medical - Lost Opportunity to Avoid Harm
 
Edry v Adelman (#279676, rel'd 12/23/08)   Zahra, Owens, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Medical - Lost Opportunity to Avoid Harm - Applicability
 
O'Neal v St John Hospital & Medical Center (#277317, rel'd 11/4/08),   Wilder, Jansen, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Medical - Lost Opportunity to Avoid Harm - Better Result - Likelihood - Calculation
 
O'Neal v St John Hospital & Medical Center (#277317, rel'd 11/4/08),   Wilder, Jansen, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Medical - Lost Opportunity to Avoid Harm/Survive - Standard - Applicability
 
O'Neal v St John Hospital & Medical Center (#277317, rel'd 11/4/08),   Wilder, Jansen, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Medical - Lost Opportunity to Survive - Applicability - Death Not Occurred
 
Edry v Adelman (#279676, rel'd 12/23/08)   Zahra, Owens, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 

NATURAL RESOURCES
   Gravel - Value
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 

NEGLIGENCE
   Duty - Necessity
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 
   Duty - Protection
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 
   Duty - Protection - Mental Health Practitioner - Purpose
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 
   Duty - Protection - Mental Health Practitioner - Third Party
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 
   Duty - Protection - Mental Health Practitioner - Third Party - Common Law - Abrogation
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 
   Duty - Protection - Mental Health Practitioner - Third Party - Definition - Other Patient
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 
   Duty - Protection - Mental Health Practitioner - Third Party - Identification - Necessity
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 
   Duty - Protection - Mental Health Practitioner - Third Party - Other Patient
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 
   Duty - Protection - Mental Health Practitioner - Third Party - Standard
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 
   Duty - Protection - Mental Health Practitioner - Third Party - Statutory/Common Law
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 
   Duty - Protection - Mental Health Practitioner - Warning - Third Party - Elements
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 

PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION
   Bindover - Evidence - Sufficiency - State of Mind
 
People v Flick (#277925, rel'd 12/23/08),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Bindover - Review - Standard - Court of Appeals
 
People v Flick (#277925, rel'd 12/23/08),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Bindover - Standard - Probable Cause
 
People v Flick (#277925, rel'd 12/23/08),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Purpose
 
People v Flick (#277925, rel'd 12/23/08),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 

PROPERTY
   Foreclosure - Sale - Tax - Notice - Constitutionality - Standing - Mortgagee - Assignee
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Foreclosure - Sale - Tax - Notice - Owner - Determination
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Foreclosure - Sale - Tax - Notice - Owner - Mortgagee - Trust Beneficiary
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Foreclosure - Sale - Tax - Notice - Owners - Necessity
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Foreclosure - Sale - Tax - Notice - Statutory - Purpose
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Foreclosure - Sale - Tax - Notice - Sufficiency - Mortgagee - Address Provided
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Forfeiture - Tax - Certificate - Effect - Notice
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Forfeiture - Tax - Notice - Certificate - Effect
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Mortgage - Recording - Effect - Inaccurate Lot Number
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Sale - Tax - Notice - Due Process - Standard
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Sale - Tax - Procedure - Statutory - Purpose - Due Process
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Sale - Tax - Redemption - Failure - Effect - Notice to Third Party
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Slander of Title
 
Lighthouse Place Development, LLC v Moorings Association (#280863, rel'd 4/28/09),   Murray, Markey, Wilder (PC)
 
 
   Slander of Title - Elements
 
Lighthouse Place Development, LLC v Moorings Association (#280863, rel'd 4/28/09),   Murray, Markey, Wilder (PC)
 
 
   Slander of Title - Elements - Malice - Advice of Counsel - Effect
 
Lighthouse Place Development, LLC v Moorings Association (#280863, rel'd 4/28/09),   Murray, Markey, Wilder (PC)
 
 
   Slander of Title - Elements - Malice - Implied
 
Lighthouse Place Development, LLC v Moorings Association (#280863, rel'd 4/28/09),   Murray, Markey, Wilder (PC)
 
 
   Slander of Title - Elements - Malice - Inference
 
Lighthouse Place Development, LLC v Moorings Association (#280863, rel'd 4/28/09),   Murray, Markey, Wilder (PC)
 
 
   Slander of Title - Elements - Malice - Question of Fact
 
Lighthouse Place Development, LLC v Moorings Association (#280863, rel'd 4/28/09),   Murray, Markey, Wilder (PC)
 
 
   Tenancy - By the Entireties - Contribution - Surviving Spouse - Maintenance of Property by Decedent - Unjust Enrichment
 
Tkachik v Mandeville 282 Mich App 364; 764 NW2d 318 (2009),   Murphy, KF KELLY, Donofrio
 
 
   Tenancy - By the Entireties - Divorce - Effect
 
Tkachik v Mandeville 282 Mich App 364; 764 NW2d 318 (2009),   Murphy, KF KELLY, Donofrio
 
 
   Tenancy - By the Entireties - Survivorship
 
Tkachik v Mandeville 282 Mich App 364; 764 NW2d 318 (2009),   Murphy, KF KELLY, Donofrio
 
 
   Tenancy - By the Entireties - Title - Conveyance - Surviving Spouse
 
Tkachik v Mandeville 282 Mich App 364; 764 NW2d 318 (2009),   Murphy, KF KELLY, Donofrio
 
 
   Tenancy - By the Entireties - Title - Unity
 
Tkachik v Mandeville 282 Mich App 364; 764 NW2d 318 (2009),   Murphy, KF KELLY, Donofrio
 
 
   Title - Chain - Name Index
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Title - Recording - Effect - Notice
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 

PROSECUTOR
   Conduct - Review - Preservation
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Conduct - Review - Standard - Constitutional/Nonconstitutional
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Conduct - Review - Standard - Preservation - Failure
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Duty/Power - Charge - Choice
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Remarks - Context
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Remarks - Defendant - Character
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Remarks - Defense Counsel - Deception
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Remarks - Evidence
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Remarks - Jury - Fear of Defendant
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Remarks - Review - Standard - Curative Instruction
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 

SCHOOLS
   Funding - State Aid - Headlee Amendment - Required Service - Increase - Costs
 
Adair v State (On Second Remand) 279 Mich App 507 (2008),   Saad, TALBOT, Fort Hood
 
 

SELF-INCRIMINATION
   Right Against - Silence - Admissibility - Noncustodial Interview
 
People v Redd (#283934, rel'd 12/4/08),   Meter, Talbot, Murray (PC)
 
 
   Right Against - Silence - Admissibility - Tacit Admission - Failure to Refute Accusation
 
People v Redd (#283934, rel'd 12/4/08),   Meter, Talbot, Murray (PC)
 
 

SENTENCING
   Guidelines - Applicability - CSC - Enhancement - Repeat Offender
 
People v Wilcox 280 Mich App 53; 761 NW2d 466 (2008),   Davis, Murray, Beckering (PC)
 
 
   Guidelines - Calculation - Facts - Findings - Verdict - Necessity
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Guidelines - Calculations - Review - Standard
 
People v Hill (#281055, rel'd 2/19/09),   Sawyer, Servitto, MJ Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Guidelines - OV 25 - Contemporaneous Criminal Acts - Contemporaneous - Definition
 
People v Hill (#281055, rel'd 2/19/09),   Sawyer, Servitto, MJ Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Guidelines - OV 25 - Contemporaneous Criminal Acts - Contemporaneous - Inference - Number of Acts
 
People v Hill (#281055, rel'd 2/19/09),   Sawyer, Servitto, MJ Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Guidelines - OV 4 - Psychological Injury - Child Sexual Abuse - Materials - Reproduction - Effect
 
People v Hill (#281055, rel'd 2/19/09),   Sawyer, Servitto, MJ Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Guidelines - OV 4 - Psychological Injury - Future Injury
 
People v Hill (#281055, rel'd 2/19/09),   Sawyer, Servitto, MJ Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Guidelines - OV 4 - Psychological Injury - Trestment - Not Obtained
 
People v Hill (#281055, rel'd 2/19/09),   Sawyer, Servitto, MJ Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Guidelines - OV 9 - Multiple Victims - Injury - Physical - Child Sexual Abuse
 
People v Hill (#281055, rel'd 2/19/09),   Sawyer, Servitto, MJ Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Guidelines - OV 9 - Multiple Victims - Victim - Definition
 
People v Hill (#281055, rel'd 2/19/09),   Sawyer, Servitto, MJ Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Guidelines - Review - Standard - Within Range
 
People v Hill (#281055, rel'd 2/19/09),   Sawyer, Servitto, MJ Kelly (PC)
 
 

STATUTES
   Agricultural Commodities Marketing Act - Assessments
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Agricultural Commodities Marketing Act - Assessments - Payment - Failure - Collection - Procedure
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Agricultural Commodities Marketing Act - Assessments - Payment - Failure - Remedy
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Agricultural Commodities Marketing Act - Assessments - Payment - Failure - Remedy - Conversion
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Agricultural Commodities Marketing Act - Assessments - Payment - Failure - Remedy - Exclusivity
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Agricultural Commodities Marketing Act - Assessments - Payment - Failure - Remedy - Exclusivity - Principal/Agent
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Agricultural Commodities Marketing Act - Payment - Failure - Liability
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Agricultural Commodities Marketing Act - Purpose
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Administrative Interpretation
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Construction - All Provisions
 
People v Flick (#277925, rel'd 12/23/08),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Construction - All Words
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 
   Construction - Ambiguity - Standard
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Amendment - Reaction to Controversy
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Common Law - Presumption
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 
   Construction - Context
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Context
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 
   Construction - Criminal - Common Law
 
People v Dupree 284 Mich App 89 (2009),   Murray (dissenting), Gleicher (concurring), MJ KELLY
 
 
   Construction - Criminal - Common Law - Defense
 
People v Dupree 284 Mich App 89 (2009),   Murray (dissenting), Gleicher (concurring), MJ KELLY
 
 
   Construction - Definitions
 
People v Flick (#277925, rel'd 12/23/08),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Definitions
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Definitions - Use of Dictionary
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Definitions - Use of Dictionary
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Legislative Intent
 
People v Flick (#277925, rel'd 12/23/08),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Legislative Intent
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Legislative Intent
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Legislative Intent
 
Hoover v Michigan Mutual Insurance Co 281 Mich App 617 (2008),   Schuette (concurring in part; dissenting in part), MURPHY, Fitzgerald
 
 
   Construction - Plain Meaning
 
People v Flick (#277925, rel'd 12/23/08),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Plain Meaning
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Plain Meaning
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Construction - Plain Meaning
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 
   Construction - Policy Choices
 
Tkachik v Mandeville 282 Mich App 364; 764 NW2d 318 (2009),   Murphy, KF KELLY, Donofrio
 
 
   Construction - Remedies - Exclusivity - Exception
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Review - Standard
 
Pierron v Pierron 282 Mich App 222; 765 NW2d 345 (2009),   Cavanagh, JANSEN, Meter
 
 
   Construction - Review - Standard
 
First National Bank of Chicago v Department of Treasury 280 Mich App 571; 760 NW2d 775 (2008),   KELLY, Cavanagh, O'Connell (dissenting)
 
 
   Construction - Review - Standard
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Review - Standard
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Construction - Surplusage
 
People v Flick (#277925, rel'd 12/23/08),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Revised Judicature Act - Remedy - Exclusivity
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 

SUMMARY DISPOSITION
   Failure to State a Claim - Review - Standard
 
Tkachik v Mandeville 282 Mich App 364; 764 NW2d 318 (2009),   Murphy, KF KELLY, Donofrio
 
 
   Failure to State a Claim - Standard
 
Tkachik v Mandeville 282 Mich App 364; 764 NW2d 318 (2009),   Murphy, KF KELLY, Donofrio
 
 
   Failure to State a Valid Defense - Standard
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Material Fact - Issue - Evidence - Admissibility - Necessity
 
Edry v Adelman (#279676, rel'd 12/23/08)   Zahra, Owens, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Material Fact - Issue - Standard
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Material Fact - Review - Standard
 
McCormick v Carrier (#275888, rel'd 3/25/08),   Whitbeck, Jansen, Davis (PC)
 
 
   Material Fact - Review - Standard
 
O'Neal v St John Hospital & Medical Center (#277317, rel'd 11/4/08),   Wilder, Jansen, Owens (PC)
 
 
   Material Fact - Review - Standard
 
Edry v Adelman (#279676, rel'd 12/23/08)   Zahra, Owens, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Review - Standard
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Review - Standard
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 

TAXATION
   General Property Tax Act - Agency - Definition
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Property - Assessment - Correction - Omission - New Construction - Partial
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Property - Assessment - Correction - Omission/Error
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Property - Assessment - Correction - Tax Commission - Appeal - Tax Tribunal
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Property - Assessment - Correction - Tax Commission - Jurisdiction
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Property - Assessment - Definition
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Property - Assessment - Valuation - Additions - New Construction
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Property - Assessment - Valuation - Additions - Omissions
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Property - Assessment - Valuation - Increase - Limitation
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Property - Assessment - Valuation - Increase - Limitation - Purpose
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Property - Assessment - Valuation - Increase - New Construction - Partial - Effect
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Property - Assessment - Valuation - Standard
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Property - Refund - Mutual Mistake - Standard
 
Briggs Tax Service, LLC v Detroit Public Schools 282 Mich App 29 (2008),   Jansen, O'CONNELL, Owens
 
 
   Tax Commission - Jurisdiction - Appellate/Administrative
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Tax Commission - Jurisdiction - Property Assessments - Correction
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Tax Commission - Jurisdiction - Stipulation - Effect
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Tax Commission - Powers - Property Assessments
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Tax Tribunal - Decision - Review - Standard - Property Tax
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Tax Tribunal - Jurisdiction - Appeals - Proceeding - Definition
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 
   Tax Tribunal - Jurisdiction - Appeals - Property Tax - Refund - Mutual Mistake - Timeliness
 
Briggs Tax Service, LLC v Detroit Public Schools 282 Mich App 29 (2008),   Jansen, O'CONNELL, Owens
 
 
   Tax Tribunal - Jurisdiction - Appeals - Tax Commission - Appeals
 
Superior Hotels, LLC v Mackinaw Township 282 Mich App 621; 765 NW2d 31 (2009),   Markey, Whitbeck, Gleicher (PC)
 
 

TORTS
   Conversion - Definition
 
Department of Agriculture v Appletree Marketing, LLC 280 Mich App 635; 761 NW2d 277 (2008),   Meter, Hoekstra, Servitto (PC)
 
 
   Defamation - Definition
 
Smith v Anonymous Joint Enterprise (#275297, rel'd 2/2/09),   Saad, Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Defamation - Elements
 
Smith v Anonymous Joint Enterprise (#275297, rel'd 2/2/09),   Saad, Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Defamation - Falsity - Necessity
 
Smith v Anonymous Joint Enterprise (#275297, rel'd 2/2/09),   Saad, Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Defamation - Falsity - Standard
 
Smith v Anonymous Joint Enterprise (#275297, rel'd 2/2/09),   Saad, Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Defamation - First Amendment - Effect
 
Smith v Anonymous Joint Enterprise (#275297, rel'd 2/2/09),   Saad, Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Defamation - Public Figure - Actual Malice - Burden of Proof
 
Smith v Anonymous Joint Enterprise (#275297, rel'd 2/2/09),   Saad, Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Defamation - Public Figure - Actual Malice - Evidence - Sufficiency
 
Smith v Anonymous Joint Enterprise (#275297, rel'd 2/2/09),   Saad, Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Defamation - Public Figure - Actual Malice - Necessity
 
Smith v Anonymous Joint Enterprise (#275297, rel'd 2/2/09),   Saad, Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Defamation - Public Figure - Actual Malice - Standard
 
Smith v Anonymous Joint Enterprise (#275297, rel'd 2/2/09),   Saad, Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 
   Defamation - Public Figure - Falsity - Knowledge - Burden of Proof
 
Smith v Anonymous Joint Enterprise (#275297, rel'd 2/2/09),   Saad, Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 

TRIAL
   New Trial - Review - Standard
 
People v Redd (#283934, rel'd 12/4/08),   Meter, Talbot, Murray (PC)
 
 
   Separate - Multiple Offenses - Separate Offenses - Waiver - Defendant/Counsel - Conflict - Effect
 
People v Houthhoofd (#269505, rel'd 2/3/09),   Beckering, Borrello, Davis (PC)
 
 

VERDICT
   Criminal - Jury - Inconsistent - Effect
 
People v Feezel (#276959, rel'd 11/13/08),   Saad (concurring in part; dissenting in part), Fort Hood, Borrello (PC)
 
 

WITNESSES
   Expert - Admissibility
 
Edry v Adelman (#279676, rel'd 12/23/08)   Zahra, Owens, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Expert - Admissibility - General Acceptance - Burden of Proof
 
Edry v Adelman (#279676, rel'd 12/23/08)   Zahra, Owens, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Expert - Admissibility - Reliability - Determination
 
Edry v Adelman (#279676, rel'd 12/23/08)   Zahra, Owens, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Expert - Admissibility - Reliability - Necessity
 
Edry v Adelman (#279676, rel'd 12/23/08)   Zahra, Owens, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Expert - Admissibility - Review - Standard
 
Edry v Adelman (#279676, rel'd 12/23/08)   Zahra, Owens, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 

WORDS AND PHRASES
   Motive
 
People v Mardlin (#279699, rel'd 5/5/09),   Zahra, O'Connell, KF Kelly (PC)
 
 
   Third Person
 
Dawe v Dr Reuvan Bar-Levav & Associates, PC 279 Mich App 552; 761 NW2d 318 (2008),   Smolenski (dissenting), WHITBECK, Kelly
 
 

ZONING
   Constitutionality - Equal Protection - Review - Standard
 
Shepherd Montessori Center Milan v Ann Arbor Township (On Remand) 280 Mich App 449; 761 NW2d 230 (2008),   SAAD, Hoekstra, Smolenski
 
 
   Exclusionary - Classification - Existent - Not Applied to Any Land
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Exclusionary - Constitutionality
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Exclusionary - Constitutionality - Burden of Proof
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Exclusionary - Constitutionality - Determination - Necessity of Use - Necessity
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Exclusionary - Constitutionality - Due Process
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Exclusionary - Constitutionality - Equal Protection
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Exclusionary - Constitutionality - Review - Ripeness - Necessity
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Exclusionary - De Facto
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Exclusionary - Master Plan - Unsuitable Land - Effect
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Exclusionary - Prohibition
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Exclusionary - Remedy - Injunction
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Exclusionary - Special Use Permit - Potential - Effect
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Exclusionary - Total - Determination
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Exclusionary - Validity
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Exclusionary - Variance - Potential - Effect
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Ordinance - Constitutionality - Due Process - As Applied - Ripeness - Necessity
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Ordinance - Constitutionality - Due Process - Review - Ripeness - Necessity
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Ordinance - Constitutionality - Due Process - Test - Rational Basis
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Ordinance - Constitutionality - Review - Ripeness - Exception - Futility
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Ordinance - Constitutionality - Taking
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Ordinance - Constitutionality - Taking - Review - Ripeness - Necessity
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)
 
 
   Ordinance - Natural Resources - Extraction - Prohibition - Validity - Expert Witnesses
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Ordinance - Natural Resources - Extraction - Prohibition - Validity - Serious Consequences - Public Interest
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Ordinance - Natural Resources - Extraction - Prohibition - Validity - Standard
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Ordinance - Natural Resources - Extraction - Prohibition - Validity - Value
 
Kyser v Kasson Township 278 Mich App 743; 755 NW2d 190 (2008),   Whitbeck, JANSEN, Davis (concurring in part; dissenting in part)
 
 
   Ordinance - Review - Ripeness
 
Hendee v Putnam Township (#270594, rel'd 8/26/08)   Donofrio, Sawyer, Murphy (PC)